Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dilshad's avatar

bring back the architect mode 😔

TechAINewb's avatar

First, I'm sorry for the long post, but I'm taking this opportunity to state my issue plainly in the hopes it might make a difference.

Full file rollback is a great step, as is diff approval. Telling the agent to re-plan the updates to a single file that got rolled back due to an implementation error takes longer to get right than manually rewriting the file. And, the approval system requires me to sit in front of it and monitor everything it does, every step of the way, in real time. Worse, I have yet to successfully convert on any task using this workflow unless I jump in and rewrite the file that was rolled back manually, or provide corrections. This goes for my personal account as well as the shop account.

And I'm not the only one. There are 12 other developers in this shop facing the exact same issues and experiencing the exact same problems.

If I have to babysit my AI and give up my ability to work in parallel, the value of an agentic programming assistant (provided by 5.x) is completely removed.

We all work on one project, and the project is built incrementally, and intentionally. The new sub-agent system seems to be optimizing for writing an entire codebase instead of implementing a single feature at a time. I appreciate wanting to support vibe coders in this way, but that's not why my shop was using kilo. It feels like 7.x dropped support for one group of developers in order to add support for the vibe code crowd. (I'm not throwing shade at the vibe coding crowd btw! I'm just saying there are other developers out here doing work using kilo)

Nothing has been more disruptive at my company than kilo's move from 5.x to 7.x, and since management believes legacy will be sunset soon, We don't have any other options, we're about to have a 3-day meeting to redevelop every single one of our workflows to adopt Claude Code.

Kilo has been the absolute best VS code plugin for me, because it fits naturally within the existing workflows of my team, and me personally. The CLI tool was excellent, but it never met those needs. The reliance on GitHub in order to enable cloud dev tools is not anything my local-dev shop will ever use (We're an on-premise outfit for various, unchangable reasons)

I know that adding new features is important to maintain market relevance, and I know that supporting the fastest growing segment of potential users is important for financial security. But, I don't think the full impact of certain choices was necessarily understood.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?